Comments on A Life In Film: The First Bullet (Milk)

Josh, James, Scott, thanks for your kind words.
2009-01-22T10:09:00.000+11:00
Josh, James, Scott, thanks for your kind words.

Scott I remember this line and Penn's thoughtful pause when he ponders it, and you're right, it beautifully captures Harvey's capacity to put ego aside and admit his failings when it serves the cause.

Cibby I'm really not a fan of biopics either. But you know what, make an exception for this one mate.

I've heard quite a bit about this, but I'm not a f...

2009-01-22T08:24:00.000+11:00

I've heard quite a bit about this, but I'm not a fan of biopics...

... if this had come out earlier, would Prop 8 have been different?

This is an absolute cracker of a review Matt, I pa...

2009-01-22T02:27:00.000+11:00

This is an absolute cracker of a review Matt, I particularly liked this idea of the first bullet fired.

Something I meant to say to you in our discussion after the film was to do with the conversation he has with Art Agnos, his opponent in the California State Assembly who tells him with honest intentions: "You know Harvey, your whole rap's a real downer."

This seemed like one of the most important exchanges in Milks political career; the simple observation that he had so far failed to relate to voters what he was for as well as what he was against. "In this town, you gotta give em a reason
for optimism or you're cooked."

I liked it because it was another stolen moment so subtly and economically captured that added significantly to my impression of Harvey as an astute and talented politician and his ability to adapt to the demands of his environment.

One of the best reviews I've read so far, Matt. I...

2009-01-21T23:53:00.000+11:00

One of the best reviews I've read so far, Matt. It makes me want to see MILK in a number of new ways, and up to now, I had rather lost interest in the film -- it being the gay cause celebre of the day/month/year.

excellent review

2009-01-21T22:36:00.000+11:00

excellent review